Note: This article is an expansion of one originally written for the Northwest Hills Civic Association (NWACA). The house is known as the McGary-Thiele house, but this article will focus on James D. McGary who built the house. More research on the Thiele connection needed: Thiele and Thielepape are early Austin names. See more about the Thielepapes in Austin https://traviscountyhistorical.blogspot.com/2018/02/audubon-blair-woods-sanctuary-fort.html
About a mile south of the southern tip of our NWACA neighborhood, at 4712 Bull Creek Road, sits a house that dates to before the Civil War. That location was part of the road to Bull Creek, hence the name, and connected with today's FM 2222 which is NWACA's southern border.
In 1979 the house was approved by the Historic Landmark Commission (HLC) to be zoned historic, but the zoning was withdrawn the same month by the city.
Fast forward to today, the current owner has filed a site plan with the City of Austin to demolish the house and the neighboring church. Because of the house's age, the City's Historic Preservation Office referred the demolition to the Historic Landmark Commission, which is scheduled to hear the case on December 2, 2026. That hearing gives the commission a chance to take another look at historic zoning for the house.
Here's some history. I have not been inside the house, so some details here from the HLC documents.
It was built ca. 1859 by James Davis McGary (1803-1880), has 18-foot ceilings and rock walls 18 inches thick; the stone is hand chiseled limestone. There are four fireplaces (two chimneys visible from outside) and the hall, an enclosed dog run AKA dog trot, is 40 feet in length and ten feet wide. The 1979 photo of the house shows external stairs; is this (or was the house originally) a story-and-a-half with access to the upper half-story via external stairs. The upper half-story/story was common in the 1800s as a sleeping or storage loft. The external stairs are not there today. (TSHA Log Architecture)
In 1979 the W.H. Passon Historical Society (Austin-based organization dedicated to preserving African American history) said the house was "an example of slave labor used in building [construction]" and deserved preservation. The connection to enslaved persons in worth a closer look.
McGary came to Austin from Missouri ca. 1859. In 1860 he registered his cattle brand; Barkley (History of Travis County and Austin) says it was one of the first in Travis County. Also in 1860 he is listed in the Travis County "slave schedules", having enslaved 12 people.
The location is in close proximity (about a mile) to two other historic properties with ties to enslaved peoples.
The Moore-Hancock farmstead, 4811 Sinclair Ave, was built ca. 1849, and thought to be Austin's last remaining log cabin on its original site. The property was purchased by Judge John Hancock in 1866.1 While a Unionist who opposed Texas's secession, he also enslaved people. He is listed in the 1860 "slave schedule" (the same year as McGary), having enslaved 15 persons. While Judge Hancock probably never lived there, it is believed several of his enslaved Black half-brothers did after the Civil War: Orange and his family, Rubin, Salem, and Payton Hancock. (Texas Beyond History)(Moore-Hancock Farmstead website)
The other property, also about a mile+ distant, is 4101 Medical Parkway. That too is thought to have been used by peoples enslaved by Hancock and built ca. 1848-49. It's a simple two-room stone building with a central fireplace. That building is today part of Heritage Park Office Plaza. (Heritage Society to Give Eight Citations Thursday, The Austin Statesman, Jan 26, 1969), (Rosedale Rambles, 1993 through 1999, Karen Sikes Collins).
These three properties shed light on the darker side of the history of the area of which NWACA is today a part. There is another question that arises: are there descendants of McGary still living with ties to the property? Black descendants of Orange Hancock still visit the Moore-Hancock property. For descendants of enslaved individuals, properties such as these can provide tangible touchstones of identity, ancestral connection, and historical truth; beyond the architectural importance they are worth preserving.
Some Neighborhood History
Diana E., who's grandparents are the namesake for Chiappero Trail, submitted a statement to the HLC which includes great history for the house and the general area. Here is her statement printed with her permission:
My family's history is deeply intertwined with the history of the property surrounding the 1859 McGary-Thiele House and the early development of northwest Austin. For more than a century, this property and the historic house across Bull Creek Road have been an integral part of our family's lives and our neighborhood's identity. I respectfully believe this landmark deserves recognition and preservation as a tangible connection to Austin's past.
On June 25, 1915, my grandparents, Mary and Norman Chiappero, purchased 78 acres in the George W. Spear League, in what was then the northwest outskirts of Austin. They established and operated a dairy at what is now 4703 Bull Creek Road. At that time, the area was largely rural, and only three houses stood nearby: the 1859 McGary-Thiele House across the road from their property and the Jung house, three lots to the south. The Jung family also operated a dairy. Located outside the city limits, both families grazed their dairy cows in the open land that is now Austin Memorial Cemetery, established in 1927. This landscape reflects an era when agriculture, open acreage, and small family enterprises characterized the outskirts of Austin.
The Chiappero family's connection to this land continued through generations. In the early 1930s, when my mother and her younger sister were teenagers, the family home burned to the ground. The family rented the McGary-Thiele House and lived there while my grandfather and his cousins rebuilt their home on the family property. That home is the house in which I live today. What began as a rural dairy operation became a multigenerational family homestead, preserving a direct link to the area's agricultural beginnings and transformation over time.
Following my grandfather's death in 1951, my grandmother sold most of her property to developers Grey and Becker. In recognition of my grandparents' connection to the land, the developers named Chiappero Trail in their honor. That street name remains a lasting reminder of the family whose dairy operation and homestead were part of the area's early history.
The McGary-Thiele House holds significance beyond its age. Local lore suggests that it may have served as a stagecoach stop in the late 1800s, a possibility that speaks to the early travel routes and settlement patterns of the area. While that account warrants further historical documentation, the house itself remains a prominent physical reminder of a period when this part of Austin was rural and sparsely settled.
For as long as I can remember, the house has had a remarkable presence in our neighborhood. Neighbors have gathered around it, walked their dogs nearby, and socialized in its surroundings. It is more than an old structure; it is a familiar landmark that connects residents to the history of the place they call home. Its continued presence provides a sense of continuity in a city that has experienced tremendous growth and change.
Five generations of my family have lived on the property across Bull Creek Road from this historic house since 1915. Our family's story is inseparable from the story of this landmark and the surrounding community. We have witnessed the transformation of this area from open farmland and dairy pastures into an established Austin neighborhood. The McGary-Thiele House stands as a rare and meaningful link to that earlier landscape and way of life.
I respectfully urge the preservation of the McGary-Thiele House in recognition of its age, its connection to the early history of northwest Austin, its place in the area's agricultural and settlement history, and its enduring significance to the surrounding community. Preserving this landmark would protect more than a historic building; it would safeguard a physical connection to the people, families, and rural landscape that helped shape this part of Austin. Once lost, this irreplaceable piece of local history cannot be recreated. Its preservation would allow future generations to experience and appreciate a part of Austin's heritage that might otherwise disappear.
Photos
Click on photos to enlarge
![]() |
| 1979 photo from Portal to Texas History. Notice outside stairs to access the second floor |
![]() |
| 1937 aerial with today's streets overlaid. McGary house with red circle |
![]() |
| Chisel marks on limestone |
![]() |
| 4101 Medical Parkway house, thought to have been the quarters of persons enslaved by Hancock |
Links
Historical marker for Moore-Hancock farmstead https://www.hmdb.org/m.asp?m=100082
James and wife Nancy are buried at Oakwood
https://www.findagrave.com/memorial/17296445/james_davis-mcgary
1 Some NWACA readers may remember the name Judge John Hancock from previous articles: he was an early owner of land in our neighborhood.





.jpg)
